Search Site
Menu
Should those who harm pets during criminal activity face additional penalties?

Without a doubt, one of the highlights of the day for people everywhere is being greeted at the front door by their favorite pet after a long day at work or school. Indeed, the reality is that the bonds many people have with their pets are so strong that they view them as more than just friends, but rather as part of the family.

Interestingly enough, lawmakers here in New York are currently considering a measure that, if passed, would introduce incredibly strict penalties, some of the harshest in the nation, for those who injure pets during the commission of a crime.

State Sen. Jim Tedisco (R-Glenville) has introduced a bill, dubbed “Kirby and Quigley’s Law” after two dogs slain during a burglary, that would make it a felony to harm a companion animal when committing criminal activity — even by accident.

Those convicted would face a $5,000 fine and two years in prison in addition to the punishment for the underlying criminal offense.

Some have likened the measure to felony murder, which enables prosecutors to bring homicide charges against those who unintentionally cause the death of another during the commission of a serious offense. By way of example, consider a pedestrian who is fatally struck by a getaway car during a robbery.

Political experts indicate that Kirby and Quigley’s Law faces something of an uphill battle. Indeed, this marks the sixth time that Tedisco has introduced some iteration of the measure, with the five previous iterations being defeated in Assembly committees.

As for the sustained reluctance in the Assembly to pass the legislation, several lawmakers have expressed concerns that the bill is 1) overly broad given its use of the term “companion animals,” 2) unnecessary given the existence of the state’s animal cruelty law, and 3) misguided in that is meant to deter cruel acts, yet punishes unintentional actions.

As for the status of the bill, it passed the Senate on a 59-2 vote last month and is once again in the Assembly.

What are your thoughts?

If you or a loved one has been charged with any manner of criminal offense — felony or misdemeanor — consider speaking with a skilled legal professional able to protect your rights and your future as soon as possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

James L. Riotto Attorney Photo
James L. Riotto
Criminal Defense Lawyer

James L. Riotto is an accomplished criminal defense attorney serving clients in New York. With an extensive background in law enforcement and criminal prosecution, his approach to each case is unique and informed by years of experience with the New York criminal justice system. As a graduate from Albany Law School and before going on to start his own practice, James worked at the Albany County District Attorney's Office, where he helped prosecute many DWI offenses. His inside knowledge of the tactics used to gain convictions provides him with a particular advantage when defending against DUI and other criminal charges.

Adam Staier Attorney Photo
Adam Staier
Of Counsel

About Attorney Adam Staier has spent the last seven years practicing criminal defense law throughout upstate New York and the Capital Region. He began his legal career through internships in civil law, indigent legal representation and federal energy law regulation. Finding a passion in criminal law, Mr. Staier held internships handling both prosecution and defense…

  • What to do if pulled over for a DUI


    How to deal with a DWI traffic stop

    How you handle getting pulled over for a DUI/DWI can significantly affect your defense down the road. For instance, declining the officer's request to search your vehicle and avoiding specific answers when asked about any substances you may have consumed could help you when combating DUI/DWI charges in court.
    READ MORE
Reviews and Ratings
  • yelp
    5.0/5.0

    I hired Jim Riotto when I was pulled over for doing 55 in a 30, in Monroe County. From the time I called him to the time he got me his amazing result, he had me well informed the whole way and could not have been better. I really appreciate everythin...

    Read more

    Patrick C.

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Mr. Riotto and his staff were such a great help for my family. Very professional, patient and kind. Thanks so much for all you do.

    Read more

    cassidy osborne

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    I went to Mr. Riotto on numerous occasions for traffic violations since I liked to ride too fast on my motorcycle and not once was I disappointed with the outcome. Then the day came when I got myself wrapped up in a criminal case. This man saved my l...

    Read more

    Enrique Lespier

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Mr. Riotto is amazing. He is very thorough, very kind and has the greatest knowledge. He handled my traffic case and the process was really smooth with the best results. If you hire Mr. Riotto, rest assured you are in great hands.

    Read more

    hemant anant jain

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Very responsive and informational,Professional. I felt confident and comfortable trusting them my traffic violation. James and his team represented me with a case of a rough traffic violation and helped me keep my record clean, I am truly grateful.

    Read more

    Mike Marcello

See all reviews
Contact us

Quick Contact Form